#1372: They Might Be Giants – Thunderbird

I’ve written about They Might Be Giants’ The Spine, or at least songs you can find on that album, many times at this point. Trying to think of a different way I could put a spin on my experiences with it, without referring to those older posts. I’m sure I’ve mentioned it’s the first physical TMBG album I owned, despite the kind of middling consensus about its quality. I may have said I got it just to hear the transition between ‘Au Contraire’ and ‘Damn Good Times’ without a gap of silence. I think I’ve said I like it a lot, may have called it “underrated” or something along those lines. It was the They Might Be Giants album the band were working on while I was finding out more about them in those early years of 2004, that might be a thing I haven’t said before. It wouldn’t be until 2009 that I got The Spine in my hands. While I don’t think ‘Thunderbird’ was a song on there I liked immediately, it wasn’t too long until it eventually burrowed itself into my head.

From what I can recall, when The Spine was the most recent or second-most recent TMBG release, ‘Thunderbird’ was one of the highest-ranked numbers from the album on the TMBG Wiki’s Song Ratings list. I think just from seeing that, it made me want to listen again and find out why fans liked it so much. I’m a guy from the UK, so when I hear ‘Thunderbird’ I think of that TV show with the puppets and Tracy Island. I did think the song was a sort of superhero theme song for a while. It sounds like one. It’s all upbeat and very driving. A power-pop tune with John Linnell providing a soaring vocal take. But then I found out that’s how the song catches you out, because the title refers to the alcoholic beverage and told from the point of view of a person who gets a huge sense of confidence after drinking it regularly. An alcoholic. I didn’t want to put ‘alcoholic beverage’ and ‘alcoholic’ in the same sentence. A happy-sounding song anchored by a not-so-happy situation. Got a Beach Boys reference in the slow breakdown and everything. As only They Might Be Giants could achieve so easily.

Until its release, ‘Thunderbird’ had been in the works for a while in the TMBG camp. The band had actually subliminally released it, in a way, in the form of ‘On Earth My Nina’ on 1999’s Long Tall Weekend. Linnell reversed ‘Thunderbird’, wrote down the words he thought he could hear, and sang them using the resulting melody line out of the backwards music. It’s definitely a way of making a song. But the band did also make a full demo of the track, also recorded in 1999. Back then, it featured an additional verse. You might say it rocked a little harder too. They performed it live between ’99 and 2001. It could have been on Mink Car in 2001. The band were really saving it, thinking about when to unleash it. I’m glad all the versions of it that are out there exist. It’s cool to note the differences. Like that demo, it really stomps. It has its own flavour. I’ve seen some say it’s flat-out better than how it finally ended up. But I really like how it is on The Spine. I couldn’t compare. I won’t. I’ll take whatever they’ve got.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.